The BAU travels to Wichita, Kansas, in search of an unsub who terrorizes parents by abducting their children while the entire family is asleep. Meanwhile, Morgan tries to find who was responsible for his attack.
- Rochelle Aytes - Savannah Hayes
- Elizabeth Bogush - Ellie Zumwalt
- Christa Beth Campbell - Josie Zumwalt
- Ronnie Coleman - Himself
- Staci Lawrence - Betty Sorenson
- Jack McGraw - Young Patrick Sorenson
- Kurt Meyer - Luke Zumwalt
- Cannon Mosteller - Ronnie Brewer
- Paul Roache - Morgue Employee
- Lauren Rubin - Lyla Brewer
- Derron "Smokey" Edington - Himself
- Aisha Tyler - Doctor Tara Lewis
- Joe Walsh - Himself
- Lucy Walsh - Sergeant Natalie Whitfield
- Reston Williams - Patrick Sorenson
- Willie J. Williams - Himself
- Bill Withers - Himself
- Cornell Womack - M.E. Cranston
- Derek Morgan: "Parents are the bones on which children sharpen their teeth." — Peter Ustinov
- Derek Morgan: "Lucky I'm sane after all I've been through. Life's been good to me so far." — Joe Walsh
- Willie J. Williams, the actor who portrayed himself, previously appeared on Criminal Minds, starring as General Williams in the Season Ten episode "Anonymous."
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.