Thread:Profiler10/@comment-36771986-20191114225348/@comment-31999953-20191114234633

Thank you and welcome to the wiki, I haven't seen you around before. I can see why you would think so but in Hamelin, Sandy specifically says that JJ's father is "off with his new wife", speaking in the present tense so he is alive based on that statement.

However, I remember when I first watched the episode, I made a particular note about Sandy's statement because I knew we had him listed as deceased here, based on Erica Messer's statement back in Season Seven. It complicates things because we have two conflicting sources that are legitimate, but it is important to note that whether he was alive or not was never addressed in an episode before. At least not as far as I'm aware. Maybe it was in Hit and Run. I don't remember those episodes all that well but usually the best policy is to go with the most recent source as it is the most up-to-date information