Thread:Fashionable101/@comment-30828576-20171027161236/@comment-31999953-20171027164705

First of all, let me just commend you for being so mature about this. It really sets a good example.

I'm going to admit that I don't know the episode very well because I haven't watched the entire thing but I have seen that particular scene where James is killed and I'm just not sure saying that Hotch killed him, as in directly caused his death, is the most accurate description of events. Like did Hotch actually cause him to fall or did James do enough of that himself? Not just because it's my personal opinion, but more because there's a similar situation with Michael Hastings two seasons later who was also killed during a struggle with JJ but we don't list JJ as having killed him. I hear what you have to say though so I'm going to compromise here.

Here's what I'll do: I will personally add an edited version of what you've added yourself: (accidental fall) and we'll leave it that way for the time being until I get the chance to review the fight myself over the next few days. Does that sound fair?